In honor of Constitution Day, and because Republicans have broken the old one, my modest proposals for restoring democracy. Note that these are all procedural changes, not policy changes. If it were up to me, FDR’s Second Bill of Rights would be in there too.
Article I: Enlarge the House of Representatives by mandating one representative for every 500,000 persons, in order to make congress more responsive. By contrast, the UK has one MP for 101,000 Britons and the Bundestag one for every 116,000 Germans. Mandate non-partisan redistricting. Enlarge the Senate, and make it more representative, by giving the 10 most populous states 1 extra senator after each census and the top 5 states 2 more after that. These Class III senators would end their terms early if their state dropped out of a population category following a census. Allow the states to chose the method of selection, either by the legislature, statewide election or (in the larger states) even by district. Make the Vice President the actual presiding officer of the senate and make all former presidents and Vice Presidents lifetime ex officio senators. The senate would be required to take a full floor vote on all legislation passed by the House within 30 days, with the possibility of a one time extension for more investigation. Likewise, all judicial nominees would have to be voted on within 30 days or become recess appointees. Congress would be given explicit law enforcement authority to enforce subpoenas or prosecute persons for contempt.
Article II: Split up the nearly dictatorial power of the executive branch by switching to a semi-presidential system. The president (directly elected by single transferable vote) would remain as Head of State, in charge of foreign policy and commander in Chief. The head of government would be a new position, the Chief Executive Officer of the United States (“prime minister” seems too European, “chancellor” sounds too academic to Americans, and “First Secretary” while more accurate sounds vaguely communist). The CEOUS would be appointed by the president but confirmed by the House, along with a Cabinet. The president could dissolve the House and call for new elections but not dismiss the CEOUS, although the House could also vote no confidence. In addition to putting more constraint on executive power this system would have the added effect of encouraging Third Parties, since coalition governments would be possible. Neither the CEOUS nor Cabinet members would be required to be members of the House. Under this system, Presidents would be more likely to be elder statesmen or international leaders (think George HW Bush or John Kerry) while the CEOUS would be held by smart tough politicians who know how to count votes (LBJ, for example, or Nancy Pelosi).
Article III: Expand the Supreme Court to 15 members and put term limits on all Federal judges (say 20 for SCOTUS, 12 for Courts of Appeal, and 10 for District Courts). Require that the President pick off a list developed by non-partisan committees in each state and Circuit, plus one for the nation as a whole. Mandate that courts must give the elective branches an opportunity to correct any Constitutional defect in legislation before striking it down. Mandate that the Courts can only declare laws Constitutional or not, not effectively rewrite them. Allow Congress or the Executive Branch to seek advisory opinions.
General: Overturn Buckley v. Valeo, Citizens United, et. al. and impose strike limits on campaign donations and expenditures. Make it clear that only natural persons have Constitutional rights, not corporations (other than the right to Due Process).
I’ve probably got some other ideas rattling around but this is it for now.